(Thanks to Guile for suggesting this episode.)
My friend Marlon once observed that whether falling in or out of love, it seems that all the songs you hear on the radio (or anywhere for that matter) are freaking relevant. It’s like the universe has conspired to drive home the point to you in musical terms (which got us thinking, “What if the world was one big musical?” wherein if a person suddenly bursts into song, the people around him are “forced”—by the laws of nature—to sing and dance along, just like in movie musicals… but that’s another topic altogether.)
Anyway, he noticed how certain songs, if heard, say, during the depths of depression, can possibly drive a person to suicide. It could be the lyrics or the music or a deadly combination of both. And so I decided to compile these songs in one cassette tape, which I dubbed “Songs To Slash Your Wrists By.”
Here I’ve attempted to update and list them down. I noticed that most of the songs are of the 60s and 70s, a reflection of my age. Sigh. I have a pet theory why: the songs from my childhood resonate more because I heard them at an age when my emotions were simpler, purer, less complicated.
So here they are. Remember that this is my personal list, not the definitive list of a generation. I attempted to rank them accordingly, but I decided not to in the end. When you’re sad, you’re just sad. (I also decided to limit my list to English-language songs first. Next time na lang ang mga Tagalog songs.)
The McVie Songs To Slash Your Wrists By:
• Crying by Roy Orbison / remake by Roy Orbison and k.d. lang. A break-up song made more mournful by the late Orbison’s operatic crooning and his plaintive plea that crescendos in the end: “I’m crying, crying o-ver yooo-u!” k.d. lang’s vocals provide the torch-song feel to the remake. To-die-for line/s: You wished me well, you couldn’t tell / that I was crying over you.
• Say Hello, Wave Goodbye by Soft Cell. Another love-gone-wrong song, about two people who realize their love for each other is no match for their differences. To-die-for line/s: You and I / we had to be the standing joke of the year.
• For No One by The Beatles. Lost love never sounded so plaintive. Paul McCartney has been accused by John Lennon for penning all those “silly love songs,” but with this song Sir Paul proves he also knows the flipside to falling in love. To-die-for line/s: And in her eyes you see nothing / no sign of love behind the tears / cried for no one / a love that should have lasted years.
• This Guy’s In Love With You by Herb Alpert. Pining for love has never been this painful or desperate. But the song’s arrangement is so deceptively relaxed and mellow, you’re seduced into the song until it’s too late and you’re trapped by the lyrics. To-die-for line/s: Say you’re in love, in love with this guy / If not, I’ll just die.
• Without You remake by Mariah Carey. I remember this song sung by a guy in the 70s. Miss Glitter’s version is more bombastic in the end, but that’s okay since it brings out the desperation in the lyrics. To-die-for line/s: You always smile / but in your eyes your sorrow shows / Yes, it shows.
• Make It Easy On Yourself by The Walker Brothers. A masochistic break-up song, the singer tells the one he loves, “If you really love him, go run to him.” Such martyrdom deserves a bullet in the head, preferable done in Luneta. To-die-for line/s: No words of consolation will make me miss you less.
• You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me by Dusty Springfield. Another masochistic song of unrequited love, Ms. Springfield is content to just be around the guy even though he has fallen out of love. Is she for real? But with the way she sings the song with conviction and without irony, you believe her when she says, “Believe me, believe me!” To-die-for line/s: Believe me, believe me, I can’t help but love you / But believe me, I’ll never tie you down.
• Cry by Godley & Cream. A cry of hopelessness, this song was made more memorable by the striking music video, with different crying faces dissolving one after the other. To-die-for line/s: You don’t know how to ease my pain / you don’t know.
• Mandy by Barry Manilow. Barry is one of those guilty pleasures. Despite the cheese factor, his rendition of this song is more heartfelt than Westlife’s remake. To-die-for line/s: I walked away when love was mine.
• Nothing Compares 2 U by Sinead O’Connor. She sings this far better than Prince, making you feel the hurt and pain especially when she reaches those high notes. To-die-for line/s: It’s been seven hours and fifteen days / since you took your love away.
• No Regrets by Midge Ure. A song from the 80s! The mournful synthesizers and drumbeats do the trick for me. To-die-for line/s: We’d only cry again / say goodbye again.
• I Will Always Love You by Whitney Houston. Here the remake is better than the original. Whitney cries the song out, pitch-perfect and full of emotion. My only quibble is the last note; where she goes up the scale with “you-oo-oo-oo!” it’s clear she’s just showing off. To-die-for line/s: If I should stay / I would only be in your way.
• The Crying Game by Boy George. The theme song from the “oh-my-god-she’s-a-he!” movie, Boy George’s singing is a pitch-perfect torch song for its time. His soulful voice contrasts beautifully with the Pet Shop Boys’ electroni-cool instrumentation. To-die-for line/s: First there are kisses / then there are sighs / and then, before you know where you are / you’re saying goodbye.
• Be My Number Two by Joe Jackson. A sad song that’s full of resignation and compromise. I especially like the arrangement: for most of the song, Joe Jackson uses only his voice and his piano, keeping things low-key. But towards the end when the drums come in and the saxophone wails, it’s the musical equivalent of a last-ditch effort at hope. To-die-for line/s: I know that it’s really not fair of me / but my heart’s seen too much action.
• Silent All These Years by Tori Amos This is one of the saddest songs I’ve ever heard even though I’m not exactly sure about half of what she’s talking about. A lone piano with an even lonelier voice—that combination always gets to me. To-die-for line/s: What’s so amazing about really deep thoughts? / Boy, you best pray that I bleed real soon / How’s that thought for you?
• No More I Love Yous by Annie Lennox I just love her voice! And when you combine that with the ethereal arrangement of the song, it’s a great ode to disillusion. To-die-for line/s: I used to have demons in my room at night / Desire, despair, desire / So many monsters.
• Ding Dong Song by Gunther and the Sunshine Girls. Currently, you can hear this song over the airwaves in stations like 101.9 For Life! and the “Kailangan Pa Bang I-Memorize Yan?” kind. Whenever I hear the refrain, I feel like slashing my wrists. To-die-for line/s: Oooh, you touch my tra-la-la! / Uhmmm, my ding-ding-dong!